CoPY: Concordance to Pylos scribal attributions
| You are currently viewing a revision titled "CoPY: Concordance to Pylos scribal attributions", saved on 2 December 2020 at 3:36 am EST by Anna P. Judson | |
|---|---|
| Title | CoPY: Concordance to Pylos scribal attributions |
| Content | CoPY: Concordance to Pylos scribal attributions
Anna P. Judson
Date created: 02/12/2020
Last update: 02/12/2020
This document functions as a concordance to show the differences between various authors’ scribal attributions of the Linear B tablets from Pylos; it does not contain any analysis of these differences or judgements between them. Users are advised to confirm all details with the original publications, and to cite those publications rather than this document as the source of all scribal hand information; however, I would be grateful for an acknowledgement (including the URL) in any publications for which you do make use of this concordance.
If you do find any errors in the concordance, please let me know via comments on this document or at apj454@gmail.com, so that they can be corrected!
This concordance was compiled during a Research Fellowship at Gonville & Caius College, Cambridge, and a Marie-Skłodowska Curie Individual Fellowship at the British School at Athens. The latter project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Skłodowska-Curie grant agreement No 885977.
References
ARN = Godart, L., and A. Sacconi. 2019-2020. Les archives du roi Nestor. Corpus des inscriptions en linéaire B de Pylos. Vol. I: Séries Aa-Fr; Vol. II, Séries Gn-Xn. 2 vols. Pasiphae XIII-XIV. Pisa/Roma: Fabrizio Serra.
Melena 1994-1995 = Melena, J.L. 1994-1995. "133 joins and quasi-joins of fragments in the Linear B tablets from Pylos." Minos 29-30: 271-88.
PT3 = Melena, J.L., and R.J. Firth. 2020. The Pylos Tablets. 3rd ed. (draft version; publication forthcoming 2021). https://www.academia.edu/44426393.
PTT2 = Olivier, J.-P., and M. Del Freo. 2020. The Pylos Tablets Transcribed. 2nd ed. Padova: libreriauniversitaria.it.
SP = Palaima, T.G. 1988. The Scribes of Pylos. Incunabula Graeca 87. Roma: Edizioni dell'Ateneo.
Numbering systems:
SP: H1-4, H6, H11-15, H21-26, H31-34, H41-45, H91 = 26 hands, plus 18 stylus groups and classes (Ci-Civ) = up to 44 writers.
PTT2: H1-8, H9A-B, H10-29, H31-34, H41-43, H44A-B, H45-47 = 42 hands in total; classes not used.
PT3: H1-8, H9A-B, H10-H34, H41-47 = 42 hands in total; plus classes (Ci-Civ).
ARN: H601-604, H606, H611-615, H621-626, H631-634, H641-643, H645, H651-659, H660?, H661-663, H691 = 37-8 hands; plus classes (Ci-Civ).
Broadly speaking, hands with the same SP/PTT2/PT3 number are equivalent to each other and to the corresponding ARN number in the 600’s (e.g. SP H1, PTT2 H1, PT3 H1, and ARN H601 are all essentially equivalent, but with differences relating to the attribution of a relatively small number of tablets).
Under each hand’s heading, tablets on whose attribution all editions identifying that hand are agreed are listed in bold; those listed with ? are either tentatively attributed to that hand by all editions, or attributed certainly by some and tentatively by others. Differences between editions are then noted in plain text.[1]
Notation:
> = change in attribution, followed by either new scribal hand number or - for another unidentified hand (in either case, ? indicates that this is not certain)
In the attached table giving an overall comparison of all four editions' scribal attributions, dark green = no difference, light green = minor difference (e.g. differences only in levels of certainty of some attributions, or reattributions of small parts of a tablet); yellow = moderate differences, red = serious differences.
Scribes are listed in numerical order from 1/601. Hands on whose identification all editions (broadly) agree but to which completely different numbers are assigned (e.g. H5/H652) are listed under both numbers.
H1/H601
Aa 240, 313, 354, 506, 662, 695, 699, 701, 717, 752, 759, 762, 764, 770, 772, 775, 777, 779, 783, 785, 786, 788, 792, 795, 798, 804, 807, 815, 854, 860, 863, 891, 955, 987, 1178, 1180, 1182
Ae 765
An 1, 37, 172, 199, 209, 261.1 ke-tu-wo-e and verso .4-.9, 292, 519 (except .4 vir 110?), 607, 610, 614, 615, 654, 656, 657, 661, 723, 724 (except VIR in .4), 830
Cn 3, 131 (except -ri-wo-ne .8?), 202, 285, 286, 328, 436 (except .1?), 437, 441, 453, 485?, 491, 570, 595.2 (VIR?), 599.8, 608, 643, 655 (except .1-.2), 702, 719 (except OVISf .3?), 925, 1059, 1197
Ed 236, 317, 411 (except .1), 847, 901
En 74, 467, 609, 659
Ep 212, 301, 539, 613, 704, 705
Eq 36, 146, 213, 1452[2]
Es 644, 645, 646, 647, 648, 649, 651, 652, 653, 703, 726, 727, 728, 729
Fg 253, 828
Na 58, 66, 69, 103, 104, 105, 106, 185, 195, 197, 198, 245, 246, 248, 252, 262, 284,[3] 296, 322, 329, 334, 342, 345, 361, 384, 394, 395, 396, 405, 406, 419 (re-u-ko-to-ro only?), 425, 466, 504, 507, 512, 513, 514, 516, 520, 522, 523, 529, 530, 531, 532, 533, 537, 540, 542, 543, 544, 547, 549, 551, 567?, 568, 571, 576, 577, 588, 604, 606, 848, 850, 856, 894, 908, 923, 924, 926, 928, 941, 986, 1009, 1013, 1016, 1021, 1025, 1037, 1038, 1039, 1040, 1041, 1044, 1052, 1053, 1054, 1086, 1089, 1091, 1092, 1106, 1175, 1179, 1362
Ng 319, 332
Nn 228, 831, 1357[4]
Un 2, 267, 592, 612, 616 verso and lat. sin.,[5] 1185
Vn 130
Wa 114, 401, 917?, 930, 948?, 1008
Xa 70,[6] 565?[7]
Xn 1097[8]
Aa 96 > H601 in ARN (H4 in others)
An 435: H1 in Melena 1994-1995, but frr. H3/Ci in SP, H3 in PTT2/PT3, H603? in ARN.
An 519.4: VIR 110 perhaps in another (unidentified) hand (PTT2, PT3).
An 1484: H601 in ARN; PT3 variously lists as H1 and -; - in PTT2; not in SP.
Cn 45: .13 and lat. inf.: H1? in SP/PT3; H601 in ARN; - in PTT2 (rest of tablet by H21/H621).
Cn 131.8: -ri-wo-ne > H21? (PTT2, PT3).
Cn 314: > H601? in ARN; Ci in SP/PT3; - in PTT2
Cn 436: .1 > - (PTT2/ARN); ‘possibly’ > Cii hand (SP/PT3)
Cn 440: H601? in ARN; Ci in SP/PT3; - in PTT2
Cn 485: H601? in ARN; H1 in others.
Cn 595.2 vir: H1 (SP/PT3), H601 (ARN); H1? (PTT2). .4-.5 also > H1 in PT3. Rest of this tablet by H21 (SP) or by H21 and another unidentified hand (.6-.7: PTT2, ARN, PT3).
Cn 600.2-.4: ideograms and numerals > - in PTT2; ‘probably’ > H601 in ARN
Cn 719.3 ovisf > - (PTT2); > H621 (ARN)
Cr 868: H601 in ARN; S868-Ci in SP; Ci in PT3; - in PTT2
Fg 374: H1 (SP/PT3), variously attributed to H1 or H1? (PTT2), > H621? (ARN)
Na 419: SA 10 > - (PTT2, ARN)
Na 567: H1? in main text of PTT2 but H1 in index; H1? in SP/PT3, H601? in ARN
Un 249: H601? in ARN; Cii in SP/PT3; - in PTT2
Un 616 recto > - in ARN/PTT2/PT3
Wa 917, 948: H1? in SP, certain in ARN/PTT2/PT3
Xa 191: H1 in SP/PTT2; - in ARN; variously listed as H1 and Ci in PT3 (Va)
Xa 1108: H1 in SP; joined to Na 197 (H1) in PT3; dejoined in PTT2 (H1) and ARN (-)
Xn 167: Ci in SP/PT3; - in PTT2; H601? in ARN
Xn 1128 - in SP/PTT2; > H1/H601 (PT3/ARN)
Xn 1460: Ci in SP; joined to Un 1185 (H1) in PT3; dejoined in ARN (H601?) and PTT2 (-)
H2/H602
Fn 187
Fr 1184, 1198, 1202, 1205, 1206, 1216, 1220, 1222, 1224, 1226, 1227, 1228, 1231, 1233, 1234, 1235, 1236, 1238, 1241, 1246, 1251
Ja 749
Jn 310, 320, 389, 410, 415, 431, 478, 601, 605, 692, 693, 725, 750, 829, 832, 845, 881, 927
Ma 90, 120, 123, 124, 126, 193, 216, 221, 222, 225, 244, 330, 333, 346, 365, 378, 393, 397
Mn 162, 456
Pn 30
Ta 641, 642, 707, 708, 709, 710, 711, 713, 714, 715, 716, 721, 722
Wa 730?
Wr 1457
Xn 991
Mn 11: H2 in SP/PTT2/PT3 (Mm); > - in ARN
Wa 730: H2? in SP; H2/H602 in PTT2/PT3/ARN
ARN adds:
Fr 1237 (Cii in SP, H30 in PT3, - in PTT2)
Fr 1243 (- in others)
Fr 1244 (Cii in SP, H30 in PT3, - in PTT2)
Jo 438 (Ci in SP/PT3, - in PTT2)
H3/H603
An 31, 35.1-.4, 101, 233, 298, 299, 424, 427, 435?, 852
Fn 7[9]
Vn 10
An 35.5-.6 > - (definite in PTT2, ARN; ? in PT3)
An 435: frr. H3/Ci in SP; H1 in Melena 1994-1995; H3 in PTT2/PT3; H603? in ARN
H4/H604
Aa 60, 61, 62, 63, 76, 85, 89, 93, 94, 95, 98
Fr 343, 1204, 1209,[10] 1211, 1212
Aa 96: > H601 in ARN; H4 in others
Fr 1194: > H604 in ARN; - in others
H5/H652 (< S733-Cii)
Sh 733, 734, 735, 736, 737, 738, 739, 740, 741, 742, 743, 744
Wa 732
No differences.
H6/H606
Un 6, 443, 853
ARN adds:
Na 841 (H16 < S337-Cii in others)
Un 1177 (Cii in PT3/SP, - in PTT2)
Un 1193 (Ci in PT3/SP, - in PTT2)
H7/H656 (< S49-Ciii)
Pa 49, 53, 398, 889
No differences.
H8 (< S155-Ci)
Cn 155, 201
Xa 200: Ciii in SP; joined to Cn 201 in PT3; dejoined and > - in PTT2/ARN
This hand does not exist in ARN, in which Cn 155 > H621; Xa 200 = Ciii; Cn 201 = Ci
H9A (< S39r-Ciii)
An 39 recto .1-.5
This hand does not exist in ARN, which attributes these lines only to Ciii.
H9B/H663 (< S39v-Ciii)
An 39 recto .7-.11 and verso, 594.1.2 (second VIR on each line)
PTT2 adds numerals and x following second VIR on An 594.1.2.
ARN adds Tn 316 recto .10 and verso (H44/H44A-B in others); tentatively adds An 724.4 second vir? (Cii in SP/PT3, - in PTT2).
H10 (< S1398-Cii)
Mb 1398, 1405
Mn 1370, 1407, 1408
This hand does not exist in ARN, which attributes Mb 1398 and 1405 to H614? and the Mn tablets to Cii.
H11/H611
An 18, Es 650 recto .1-.6, .7 wo-ro-ti-ja-o, .8A ka-ra-i, and verso
Es 650: r.7.8.A (apart from the first word of each of these lines) and .8B > - in PTT2/ARN.
H12/H612
An 1281, Vn 851 (except .13 ma-so-ni-jo 2̣?)
Vn 851.13: second entry > - in PTT2/ARN.
H13/H613
Ae 629, 634
La 622?, 623, 624?, 626, 627?, 630, 631?, 633?, 1393?
Wr 1359?
La 622, 624, 627, 631, 633: S622-H13? in SP, > H13/H613 in PTT2/PT3/ARN
La 632, 635: H613 in ARN; H28 in PTT2/PT3 (< S632-Ciii in SP)
La 994: > H613?? in ARN (Civ? in SP/PT3; - in PTT2)
La 1393: S622-H13? in SP; H13? in PTT2; > H13 in PT3/H613 in ARN
Wr 1359: S622-H13? in SP; H13? in PTT2; > H13 in PT3; > - in ARN
H14/H614
Mb 1363, 1364, 1365, 1376, 1377, 1378, 1379, 1380, 1383, 1387, 1396, 1397, 1399, 1401, 1404, 1429, 1430, 1431, 1432, 1434, 1435, 1436
Mn 1367, 1368, 1369, 1371, 1409, 1410, 1411, 1412
ARN adds:
Mb 1381 (Cii in SP/PT3, - in PTT2)
Mb 1398? and 1405? (H10 in PTT2/PT3 < S1398-Cii)
Ua 158 (Cii in SP/PT3, - in PTT2)
Ua 1413 (Ci in SP/PT3, - in PTT2)
ARN removes: Mb 1366 > - (H14 in all others)
H15/H615
Qa 1259, 1290, 1291, 1292, 1293, 1294, 1295, 1296, 1297, 1298, 1299, 1301, 1302, 1303, 1304, 1306, 1308, 1309, 1310, 1311, 1312, 1441
Un 219
No differences.
H16 (< S337-Cii)
Na 337, 561, 841, 1027[11]
Wa 1093?
This hand does not exist in ARN, in which:
Na 337, Wa 1093 > H661
Na 561, 1027 > H662
Na 841 > H606
H17/H658 (< S1203-Cii)
Fr 1200, 1201, 1203, 1208
No differences.
H18/H657 (< S1217-Cii)
Fr 1217, 1218, 1225, 1240, 1242
ARN adds Fr 1223 (H44 in SP/PT3; - in PTT2)
H19/H659 (< S1219-Cii)
Fr 1215, 1219, 1221
ARN tentatively adds Fr 1230? (H30 in PT3, Cii in SP, - in PTT2)
H20/H651 (< S1272-Ciii)
Ac 1272, 1274, 1275, 1276, 1277, 1278, 1279, 1280
Wr 1326
No differences.
H21/H621
Ab 186, 189, 190, 194, 210, 217, 277, 355, 356 (except ra-qi-ti-ra2?), 372, 379, 382, 388, 417, 468, 515, 553, 554, 555, 558, 559, 560, 562, 563, 564, 573, 575, 578, 580, 582, 584, 585, 586, 745, 746, 789, 899, 946, 978, 1099, 1102, 1103, 1109, 1115
Aq 64, 218
Cc 660, 665, 1258, 1283, 1284, 1285
Cn 4, 40, 45 (except .13, and laf. inf.?), 254, 595.1-.3 (except VIR in line .2), 599 (except .8) 600 (except for ideograms/numerals on .2-.4?), 655.1-.2, 938, 962
Fg 368[12]
Jn 658, 706
Ab 356: ra-qi-ti-ra2 > - in ARN; > -? in PTT2.
Cn 45: .13 and lat. inf.: H1? in SP/PT3; H601 in ARN; - in PTT2 (rest of tablet by H21/H621).
Cn 131.8: -ri-wo-ne > H21? in PTT2/PT3 (rest of tablet is by H1/H601).
Cn 595: SP: H21, apart from vir in .2 (H1).
PTT2: .1-.5 by H21, apart from vir in .2 (H1?); .6-.7 > -
ARN: .1-.5 by H621, apart from vir in .2 (H601) ; .6-.7 > -
PT3: .1-.3 by H21, apart from vir in .2 (H1); .4-.5 > H1; .6-.7 > -?
Cn 600.2-.4: ideograms and numerals > - in PTT2; ‘probably’ > H601 in ARN
ARN adds:
Cn 155 (H8 in PTT2/PT3 < S155-Ci in SP)
Cn 719.3 ovisf (> - PTT2; H1 in SP/PT3 along with rest of tablet)
Fg 374? (H1 in SP and PT3; H1? in PTT2)
H22/H622
Ae 142, 344
An 129, 192, 340
No differences.
H23/H623
Ad 289, 290, 295, 308, 315, 318, 326, 357, 380, 390, 663, 664, 666, 667, 668, 669, 670, 671, 672, 675, 676, 677, 678, 679, 680, 683, 684, 685, 686, 688, 689, 690, 691, 694, 697, 700, 921
No differences.
H24/H624
Er 312, 880
Un 718
Wa 731
ARN adds:
Sa 22? (Ciii in SP/PT3, - in PTT2)
Wr 1437 (- in all others)
H25/H625
Vn 20
No differences.
H26/H626
Sa 287, 403, 483, 487, 488, 682, 751?, 753, 755, 758, 760, 761, 763, 766, 767, 768, 769, 774, 787, 790, 791, 793, 794, 796, 797, 834, 840, 843, 1264, 1265, 1266?, 1267
Wa 1148, 1271?
Sa 751: H26 in SP/PT3/PTT2; > H626? in ARN
Sa 1266: H26? in SP/PT3/PTT2; > H626 in ARN
Sa 1313: H26 in SP/PTT2; > H26? in PT3; > - in ARN
Sa 1561: not in SP; H26 in PTT2; H626? in ARN; - in PT3
ARN adds:
Sa 137 (Cii in SP; - in PTT2; variously listed as Cii or H26 in PT3)
Tn 316 r.1-.5 (H44 in SP/PT3; H44A in PTT2)
H27/H660? (< S628-Ciii)
La 628, 640
Wr 1360 included by SP and PT3 (> - in PTT2; Ciii in ARN)
ARN regards the attribution of these two tablets to the same hand as doubtful (no other tablets attributed to their possible hand 660).
H28 (< S632-Ciii)
La 632, 635
PT3 adds La 1394 (Ciii in SP/ARN, - in PTT2)
This hand does not exist in ARN, which adds La 632 and 635 to H613.
H29 (< S1331-Ci)
Wr 1325, 1330, 1331, 1332, 1333, 1334
This hand does not exist in ARN, which classes all of these only as Ci (although noting that 1325 and 1334 are probably by the same hand, who could also have written 1331 and 1332).
H30
Fr 1230, 1232, 1237, 1244, 1255, 1338, 1355
This hand is identified only by PT3. All attributed to Cii only in SP; unattributed in PTT2.
ARN also identifies these only as Cii, except Fr 1230: H659?; Fr 1237 and 1244: H602.
H31/H631
Cn 1287
Ub 1315
No differences.
H32/H632
Ub 1316, 1317, 1318 (except .6 u-po , ka-ra?)
Ub 1318.6 u-po , ka-ra > -? in ARN/PTT2.
H33/H633
Qa 1289, 1300, 1305
Qa 1307: H33 in SP, now joined to Qa 1303 = H15/H615
H34/H634
Un 1321
Wo 1199 (ex Wr) included by SP; tentatively included by PTT2 and PT3; excluded by ARN.
H41/H641
Eb 149, 152, 156, 159, 169, 173, 177, 294, 297, 321, 338, 339, 347, 364, 369, 377, 416, 464, 472, 473, 477, 495, 496, 498, 499, 501, 502, 534,[13] 566, 636, 747, 818, 835, 839, 842, 846, 858, 859, 861, 862, 866, 871, 872, 874, 877, 884, 885, 886, 890, 892,[14] 893, 895, 900, 903, 905, 913, 915, 916, 934, 954, 957, 964, 976, 985, 993, 1082, 1174, 1176, 1186, 1187, 1188, 1345, 1347, 1352, 1425, 1440
Ed 411.1
Eo 160, 211, 224, 247, 268, 269, 276, 278, 281, 351, 371, 444, 471
Fr 1207
Wa 784
No differences.
H42/H642
Ae 8, 26, 27, 72, 108, 110, 134, 264, 303, 489
An 128
Fa 16
Ua 9, 17, 25, 434
Un 47, 138
Va 482
ARN adds:
Ja 1288 (Cii in SP/PT3; - in PTT2)
Va 404?, 1323, 1324 (all Cii in SP/PT3; - in PTT2)
H43/H643
An 207, 261 (recto, except .1 ke-tu-wo-e; verso .1-.2)
Ea 28, 29, 52, 56, 57, 59, 71, 102, 109, 132, 136*, 208, 259, 270, 304, 305 (except the first -na-?), 309, 325, 336, 421, 439, 460, 480, 481, 754, 756, 757, 771, 773, 776, 778, 780, 781, 782, 799, 800, 801, 802, 803, 805, 806, 808, 809, 810, 811, 812, 813, 814, 816, 817, 820, 821, 822, 823, 824, 825, 827, 882, 922, 1000, 1406?, 1424
*Ea 936 (H43 in SP) joined to Ea 136 in PT3; dejoined in PTT2 and ARN dejoin and Ea 936 > -
Ea 305: first -na- > - in PTT2/ARN
Ea 1406: SP variously attributes this (as Mb 1406) to H43? and H43; H43 in PTT2/PT3/ARN.
H44(A/B)
Tn 316
Tn 316: SP and PT3 attribute this tablet to a single hand; PTT2 attributes it to two hands, H44A (recto) and H44B (verso).
Fr 1223 also included by SP and possibly PT3*; - in PTT2, H657 in ARN
Tn 996 possibly included by PT3*; - in PTT2, Ciii in SP/ARN
*variously attributed to H44 and to Ciii in different parts of this draft edition.
This hand does not exist in ARN, which attributes Tn 316 recto .1-.5 to H626 and recto .10 and verso to H663.
H45/H645
Fn 41, 79, 837, 867,[15] 918, 965, 966, 970, 972, 973, 974, 975, 979, 989
No differences.
H46
Ae 995
This hand is identified only by PTT2 and PT3; Ae 995 is part of H91/H691 in SP/ARN, along with Xa 1419 (H47).
H47
Xa 1419
This hand is identified only by PTT2 and PT3; Xa 1419 is part of H91/H691 in SP/ARN, along with Ae 995 (H46).
H91/H691
Ae 995
Xa 1419
Xn 1449 included in SP; now joined to Vn 1339 (Ciii in PT3/ARN; - in PTT2)
This hand is identified only in SP and ARN; PTT2 and PT3 split it into two, H46 (Ae 995) and H 47 (Xa 1419).
H651/H20 (< S1272-Ciii)
Ac 1272, 1274, 1275, 1276, 1277, 1278, 1279, 1280
Wr 1326
No differences.
H652/H5 (< S733-Cii)
Sh 733, 734, 735, 736, 737, 738, 739, 740, 741, 742, 743, 744
Wa 732
No differences.
H653 (< S300-Cii)
On 300
This hand does not exist in PT3 (Cii) or PTT2 (-).
H654
Vn 48, 493, 865
This hand exists only in ARN.
SP: all Ci.
PT3: Vn 48 Cii, Vn 493 and 865 Ci.
PTT2: all -.
H655
Un 1314[16]
Va 15
This hand exists only in ARN.
SP and PT3: both Cii
PTT2: both -.
H656/H7 (< S49-Ciii)
Pa 49, 53, 398, 889
No differences.
H657/H18 (< S1217-Cii)
Fr 1217, 1218, 1225, 1240, 1242
ARN adds Fr 1223 (H44 in SP/PT3; - in PTT2)
H658/H17 (< S1203-Cii)
Fr 1200, 1201, 1203, 1208
No differences.
H659/H19 (< S1219-Cii)
Fr 1215, 1219, 1221
ARN tentatively adds Fr 1230? (H30 in PT3, Cii in SP, - in PTT2)
H660?/H27 (< S632-Ciii)
La 628, 640
Wr 1360 included by SP and PT3 (- in PTT2; Ciii in ARN)
ARN regards the attribution of these two tablets to the same hand as doubtful (no other tablets attributed to their possible hand 660).
H661
Na 337
Wa 1093
These tablets form part of H16 (< S337-Cii) in the other editions, along with Na 561 and 1027 (H662) and Na 841 (H606).
H662
Na 561, 1027
These tablets form part of H16 (< S337-Cii) in the other editions, along with Na 337 and Wa 1093? (H661) and Na 841 (H606).
H663/H9B (< S39v-Ciii)
An 39 recto .7-.11 and verso, 594.1.2 (second vir on each line)
PTT2 adds numerals and x following second vir on An 594.1.2.
ARN adds Tn 316 recto .10 and verso (H44/H44A-B in others); tentatively adds An 724.4 second vir? (Cii in SP/PT3, - in PTT2).
Notes
[1] Differences between SP and the newer editions which are due to joins or series reclassifications are not generally noted, unless they have resulted in a significant change of scribal attribution or unless the joins themselves differ between editions. Likewise, the division of series into sets by PT3 is omitted for the sake of simplicity.
[2] Dejoined from Eq 36 by ARN/PTT2; join maintained in PT3.
[3] Dejoined from Na 262 in PTT2/ARN; join maintained in PT3.
[4] Reclassified as Na(1) in PT3.
[5] verso classified separately as An(2) 616 in PT3.
[6] Reclassifed as Na(1) in PT3.
[7] Reclassified as Na(1) in PT3.
[8] Xa in PT3.
[9] ex An; PT3: Bn.
[10] Fr 1209 de-joined from 1211; joined to 343 in PTT2 and ARN, but not in PT3.
[11] ΝΒ this is omitted (apparently accidentally) from the list of H16’s tablets in PT3 section 3 (it is consistently attributed to H16 elsewhere).
[12] Reclassified as Ab in PT3.
[13] Joined to Eb 501 in PT3; dejoined in PTT2 and ARN.
[14] Joined to Eb 499 in PT3; dejoined in PTT2 and ARN.
[15] Joined to Fn 837 in PT3; dejoined in PTT2 and ARN.
[16] classed as Vn in PT3. |
| Excerpt | |
| Footnotes |