An analysis of William Foy’s visions are compared with Ellen White’s, noting that the two shared the same vision. Both visions are ultimately traced to the apocryphal work of 2 Esdras, popular among Millerites, allowing us to analyze how both Foy and White utilized the Apocrypha in their visionary renditions. Furthermore, this analysis sheds light on how Ellen White conceived of the ability for prophets to commit error and what her own self-evaluation was when she referred to herself as a lesser light pointing to the Bible.